Read Senior Editor Laura Washington's 8 reasons to make a tax-deductible donation to In These Times.
ZoomZoom InZoom OutPrintDiscuss
Culture > February 23, 2005

Return of the Elves

By James Parker

Magic—or more precisely, the “magical”—was one of the first casualties of punk rock. As guitar solos contracted and song structures were shaved to a stump, with amazing speed we lost our dragons, our druids, our talking trees—the whole seeping, twittering realm of the fantastic was suddenly banished, as if by a lobotomy. It survived, lurkingly, in the lower realms of heavy metal and Goth, but no one would ever again fill a stadium by singing about Gollum, the evil one. Punk rock had killed the elves.

Or had it? Dead Meadow, a quartet from Washington, D.C., whose fourth studio album Feathers was released by Matador on Feb. 22, are on a mission back into the magical. Schooled in D.C.’s punk and post-punk scenes, singer-guitarist Jason Simon and bassist Steve Kille discovered, almost as soon as they began playing together, a shared attraction to a state of pre-punk awe. “We found ourselves trying to get back to the music that had blown our minds as kids,” says Kille. “Pink Floyd, Led Zeppelin, the records your older brother played you.” A steady stream of literary intoxicants—J.R.R. Tolkien, H.P. Lovecraft—flowed into the music, and the sound of Dead Meadow was born: spacious, weighty, enthralling, an almost ritualized reenactment of the moment at which ’60s airy-fairyness nosedived into ’70s drug rock.

“From the heights of the town/ her handmaids will announce/ her undying presence within/ the seven-pillared house,” run the lyrics to “At Her Open Door.” “We’re definitely looking for that escapist feel,” says Kille. “You know, you’re 10 years old, sitting on a shag rug, dreaming about other worlds.” The creation of other worlds demands a grand sense of scale, of the highs and the lows. On Feathers, vintage psychedelia is earthed in a rugged blues-metal base, and titanic riffing suddenly softens to the opiated trudge of Dark Side of the Moon-era Pink Floyd.

In a happy irony, it was the DIY climate of D.C.’s famously intense punk scene that empowered these musicians to take the plunge, to telescope backward into the music of their dreams. “I think it’s just the nature of growing up in that area,” says Kille. “You feel like you can do it, follow your own vision.”

Not easily pigeonholed, Dead Meadow’s music has been called everything from stoner rock to psychedelic revivalism. “The labels don’t make much sense to me,” says Kille. “Are we a heavy band? Are we a melodic band? I think we’re a pop band that plays heavier songs, which is maybe how Black Sabbath would have described themselves, before the whole idea of ‘heavy’ got so rigid and prefabricated.”

Dead Meadow’s capacity for unforced heaviness is indeed remarkable. There is no oppression in their volume. Their heaviest moments have a quality of subsidence, of something gentle yet enormous sleepily changing position. Nothing breaks the reverie. “You read an Edgar Allan Poe story,” says singer-guitarist Simon, “and it’s all about keeping a mood, maintaining a certain mood and holding it through every word and phrase. And in music, if you’re trying to match every note to a certain feeling it becomes almost like a raga. How can we hold this feeling through a whole song?”

Simon’s frail, drifting voice—like a less virtuosic Thom Yorke (of Radiohead)—is the emotional key to Dead Meadow, undercutting the epic strokes of his guitar with a sort of wonderstruck humanness. Simon is almost addicted to wonder—his list of favorite fantasy writers goes way beyond H.P. Lovecraft, into the less charted territory of Algernon Blackwood, William Hope Hodgson and the Londoner Arthur Machen, whose 1914 story, “The Bowmen,” was directly responsible for the World War I legend of the Angels Of Mons, in which archers from the age of Agincourt appeared over the battlefield and rained celestial arrows on the German army.

“These writers, to me, are just a celebration of pure imagination,” Simon says. “And it seems like the imagination is suffering these days—so many images coming at you, so shallow and so fast. We’re trying to create songs with some space in them, some imaginative space, to give people some room.”

James Parker, an In These Times contributing editor, is the author of Turned On: A Biography of Henry Rollins

More information about James Parker
  • subscribe to print magazine

  • Reader Comments

    In typical American musical ignorance ITT does not realize that European Heavy Metal bands including Iron Maiden, Helloween, Blind Guardian, Manowar (American) Hammarfall, Gamma Ray, Rhapsody and countless others have been working with fantasy based themes scince the late 80’s. Look up any band labled powermetal and you will find some of these themes and some mind blowing musicianship.

    Posted by Jacob on Mar 22, 2005 at 3:52 PM

    In typical metal musical arrogance, Jacob assumes readers of ITT give a damn about European heavy-metal bands -yawn. Mind blowing musicianship - it goes to eleven dude.

    Posted by Nigel Tufnell on Mar 23, 2005 at 11:27 AM

    “Rock journalism is people who can’t talk talking to people who can’t write writing for people who can’t read.”
    –Frank Zappa R.I.P.

    Every few years every magazine must do the obligatory “rock is dead/long live rock” story.

    Nothing to see here, move along.

    Posted by Elvis on Mar 28, 2005 at 12:30 AM

    great zappa quote that - GENIUS - what a seer that man was… i also take great comfort and intellectual nutrition from his ‘toast is to jam as fish are to bicycles’ and ‘a woman needs a man who looks like a fish’ (wait - was that right?...) anyway - brilliant use above of the devastating zappa-wisdom - towering mental superiority - truly devastating to all who have ever written, read or stared illiterately at a crowded page. now move along. PLEASE.

    Posted by twinky on Mar 28, 2005 at 9:10 AM

    You’re right, twinky. I apologise for using Zappa as a cover for my lack of genuine cerebration. I was having a bad night - my dog has a rash. Having read through the article again, I can see the writer’s point. It is thoughtfully made, and quite interesting. Maybe I’ll buy the record.

    Posted by Elvis on Mar 28, 2005 at 9:16 AM
  • extended discussion >>>Continued...

    Discussions with more than 5 comments are continued on our special discussion page to encourage continuity and ease of use. There are currently 6 posts.

Join Here
Member Login

Forgot password?

Article Appeared in this Issue

Full contents
Past issues


Donate now
and get a
free, signed copy
of Rick Perlstein's new book Nixonland: The Rise of a President and the Fracturing of America!

Popular Discussions