Views » July 3, 2007 » Web Only

Rocking Out To Our Demise

It’ll take more than outdoor concerts to stop global warming

By Megan Tady

Last week, with the thermometer surpassing “miserable” here in Massachusetts, people hauled out hulking air conditioners and implanted them in windows. The hum of the machines spread out across town sounded like a buzzing swarm of locust to me.

Outside, the smog index rose, and the hills in the distance looked like a fuzzy Polaroid.

“Ah,” a friend said sardonically, “at least we know that global warming is working.” What isn’t working, it appears, is our commitment to cut our carbon footprint.

Wasn’t it less than three months ago that thousands of people across the United States gathered in town commons, on beaches, in fields and on sidewalks to give the Earth one large promise ring? We were “stepping it up” for a goal of 80 percent emissions reductions by 2050, and so, as the theory went, would our pressured politicians.

But as July begins, it’s clear that many of us have gotten cold feet. And while we wait for another organized day of action where we can proudly wave our homemade banners and recommit to saving the planet, many of us are doing nothing on a daily basis to help right this ship; and that ship, it seems, is sailing directly toward one of the rapidly diminishing icebergs.

In this month’s issue of Harper’s magazine, environmentalist and author Bill McKibben has an ominous message: “The Kyoto Protocol we didn’t sign will expire in 2012, and negotiations are beginning for whatever will succeed it. Unless there’s a U.S.-led effort to produce something truly dramatic, the world might as well not bother.”

Journalist George Monbiot, currently traveling the United States to promote his book Heat—possibly for the last time, as he’s sworn-off flying—told In These Times last month that governments are quietly pushing back the “2 degrees” emissions target.

That is, if they’re even talking about the target. Laboring in Congress right now is an energy bill so devoid of real action on global warming that Democratic leaders are already assuring they will push for separate climate change legislation later this year. Uh … so what’s in this bill?

It’s obvious a people-led shove is in order to get the U.S. government to act. But three months after we “stepped it up,” momentum on the part of our bumbling, bought-out bureaucrats seems to be slow.

Jennifer Krill, a program director with the Rainforest Action Network, tells me that the climate change movement has “ebbs and flows,” particularly because students are on summer break. She assures me the climate change momentum has not died down.

Of course, that might be true only if you consider Al Gore’s Live Earth concerts, the Climb A Presidential Peak campaign, and innocuous petition drives “momentum.”

With so many environmentalists and scientists waving their hands and screaming, “This is an emergency,” can we really afford to rock out to John Mayer? And “momentum” seems to imply that we’re building on to something that was already powerful, but really, we’ve only “stepped up” our recycling, “stepped up” our Prius driving, and “stepped up” our sweater wearing—one of Al Gore’s famous instructions for combating climate change.

Left out of the plan is any understanding that our entire energy system (and economic way of life) has to be completely restructured in order to truly thwart global warming. But instead of talking about how we can bring corporate polluters to their knees, oust our lying leaders and undermine a system that favors profit over people—which leads inexorably to the destruction of the planet, no matter how warm your sweater—we’re told to clap along at feel-good concerts, sponsored by the likes of Chevy and Phillips.

Krill says the climate change movement is gearing up for the fall, when a new coalition called “No War, No Warming” is planning a “National Intervention” in Washington, D.C. in October. Great, I’ll see you there. But if we’re serious about combating global warming, we need to face the fact that actions like this give people the illusion that protests alone are enough to prompt social change.

Such events do not rock the boat, do not challenge the global economic system, do not hold our elected officials accountable and certainly do not move people to act in any radical way after the event is over. Rather, they allow us to return to our homes, put our posters away and turn on the A/C with just a twinge of guilt. Oh what the heck, we can repent in October.

Or, we can seek out actions that approach the problem for what it is: the most dangerous we face. To quote activist and author Peter Gelderloos, “If a movement is not a threat, it cannot change a system.”

Author and environmentalist Derrick Jensen told me, “This culture is killing the planet, and the response is things like this: ‘Folks all over will be gathering for parties, solidarity concerts, and to view the global concerts together on TV.’ That is the sort of response? That is pathetic.”

Instead, Jensen says, “We need to act with a passion and decisiveness to match the situation, and to match the danger this culture has created. The world will not be saved from this culture by parties and concerts, and it is harmful and absurd to pretend it will be. What we must do to stop this culture from killing the planet: we must deprive the rich of their ability to steal from the poor, and the powerful of their ability to destroy the planet.”

Krill says actions like the Step It Up campaign increase awareness of global warming, and have prompted more people to take actions like switching to compact-fluorescent light bulbs in their homes.

Good. But this ship is going under, and “doing something truly dramatic” needs to include a lot more than tossing out light bulbs.

• Help In These Times publish more articles like this. Donate today!
• Subscribe today and save 46% off the newsstand price!

• subscribe to print magazine

• stay in touch with our email newsletter

  Subscribe to our regular weekly e-mail newsletter. It's packed with updates on recent and upcoming stories, events, campaigns and things every progressive should be informed about.

   

• email this article to a friend

  Your Name Your Email Recipient Email

  Personal message Thought you might be interested in this article from In These Times.

   

  Please help us prevent spam by verifying the word you see in the image above

  Send to multiple recipients. Just separate each email address with a comma.

• Reader Comments

  So what can we do? I’m just one person, I’m not a politician.  What can I do to affect real change?  It’s pretty hard not to feel powerless.  How are we going to change the corrupt system that we live in?

  Posted by cocoba on Jul 3, 2007 at 4:40 PM

  I found the article to be half brilliant and half stupidly irresponsible.  Brilliant because it is trying to point out that mass culture change is required to solve the climate change crisis.  Stupidly irresponsible because your call to “bring corporate polluters to their knees, oust our lying leaders and undermine a system that favors profit over people” utterly misses the reality of our cultural conundrum.  One, what are we suppose to do with our economy on its knees, our leaders ousted, and our “system” undermined. Isn’t it a bit irresponsible to call for destruction without having a positive replacement, even one vague idealistic reference to a replacement?  I mean really irresponsible like polluting the planet is irresponsible.  Like how a mass media that doesn’t talk about what is really going on is irresponsible.  Just as cheap and just as easy.

  Two: who, pray tell, can bring polluters to their knees, make leaders tell the truth, and force the system to prefer people over profits.  Why it’s the people who have addicted themselves to the goods of our polluting economy, who are so deferential to our lyng leaders, and who sustain with their unbending passivity the system that screws them over and over.  And this will go on and on while the Left plays it’s mindlessly righteous tunes and Rome burns. 

  Get over your addiction to dead ideas that stir your blood with convictions of “justice” and make you feel right and superior, but cannot propose anything feasible.  Get real and face the daunting fact that nobody is really addressing what needs to be done.  That is, to fashion TOGETHER a new politics out of our intelligence, compassion, and imagination, one that holds ORDINARY PEOPLE accountable for their deference and passivity so that they can take RESPONSIBILITY for their behavior, and thereby tap into their inherent POWER and capacity to COLLABORATE .  Then we can begin to create a DEMOCRACY, that can functionally replace our mass-supported oligarchy.  Anything else—left, right, or center—is cheap talk.

  joncehart

  Posted by joncehart on Jul 4, 2007 at 11:10 AM

  Joncehart - You have it exactly right!  We are the problem.  There are no “leaders” who are going to try and fix this or any other issue because it’s the right thing to do or because a few people hold a protest or concert.  The American people have to want to change and then the “leaders” will follow.

  I live in the Midwest, and trust me, 50% or more of the people here still do not believe that Global Warming is a real issue.  They feel that Al Gore made it up and that it is a Dem scare tactic.

  This past year my family and I have started going green as much as we can.  Conserving our water, electricity, going vegetarian etc.  I work for a Fortune 500 company and most of my co-workers (college educated people) think I’m out of my mind.

  We have to find a way to educate and win over the American people and getting on soap boxes and pontificating will just turn people off.

  GRIST, The Daily Show, and Colbert - are all on the right track.  We have to educate in an entertaining way and then people will hopefully listen and “get it”.

  As the great sage of our age put it, ” Here’s what I think the truth is: We are all addicts of fossil fuels in a state of denial, about to face cold turkey. ”  Kurt Vonnegut

  Posted by crossroads3885 on Jul 4, 2007 at 12:10 PM

  Since any viable left has been dead in this country for years, we may never get beyond “feel good”  attempts at solutions to the looming catastrophes that await us.  The social changes needed to turn the climate situation around will not take place, and for the same reason that we have such a mess on our hands in the educational and health sectors. We have even outsourced our wars. We have bought into the idea that business, combined with individual initiative,  can solve all our problems. It is pretty obvious that this is not true, but on and on we go and the failures mount up.

  Posted by Hattie on Jul 4, 2007 at 5:15 PM

  When will anyone out there writing about global warming learn about the HAARP program?  They are experimenting with the Ozone layer of our ionosphere; and DOE is running chemtrails to “adjust” our weather so they can continue damaging our ionosphere.  Senate Bill 517 is on the dock to allow this to be funded and continued. 

  Here is a serious scientific documentary about HAARP:
  http://www.guba.com/watch/2000915475?category_id=525&duration_step=0&fil lter_tiny=0&pp=40&sb=5&set=5&sf=0&size_step=0&o=17&s sample=1181546641:75f761e7edefe279f6989f32ce499fed4be2bc87

  Posted by Yellowbird on Jul 4, 2007 at 9:56 PM

• extended discussion >>>Continued...

  Discussions with more than 5 comments are continued on our special discussion page to encourage continuity and ease of use. There are currently 6 posts.

Also by Megan Tady

• Just Say No to Mega-Media Marriages
  It's a bad marriage--the kind that makes you want to run down the… morePosted on December 10, 2009
• Consolidation Station: News ‘Sharing’ Erodes Journalism
  Television broadcasters in the Aloha State have been quietly embarking on an underhanded… morePosted on November 3, 2009
• Drowning Out the Noise Machine
  Journalism is breaking my heart. Or should I say, "journalism." Hate-mongering media extremists… morePosted on September 29, 2009
• Will ‘Astroturf’ Groups Block Net Neutrality Reform?
  Chris McGreal, a reporter for Britain's Guardian newspaper, took to the road last… morePosted on September 2, 2009
• Mr. President, Help Save the News
  In late July, former CBS news anchor Dan Rather sent murmurs through the… morePosted on August 5, 2009