Views > August 24, 2007 > Web Only

Mining Roves Katrina Legacy

Rove was the man President Bush quietly put in charge of overseeing the administration’s response plan, though he had no expertise in homeland security or disaster relief

By Amanda Terkel

Karl Rove isn’t called a “mastermind” for nothing. He announced his resignation at the perfect time—right before the second anniversary of Hurricane Katrina, which hit the Gulf Coast on Aug. 29, 2005.

The media talked about his role in the CIA leak investigation, the U.S. attorney scandal, GOP election victories (and failures), and the Iraq war—all important topics. But they largely ignored his management of the administration’s bungled response to Hurricane Katrina.

We all remember “Brownie,” the incomprehensibly incompetent FEMA director Michael Brown, who had no idea evacuees were using the New Orleans convention center as an evacuation shelter. But Rove was the man President Bush quietly put in charge of overseeing the administration’s response plan. Rove had no expertise in homeland security or disaster relief. His role was to make sure that the reconstruction efforts enhanced Bush’s political image.

By almost all accounts, Rove failed. One of the most memorable images from Hurricane Katrina is Bush looking out the window of Air Force One at the Gulf Coast destruction below, symbolizing an out-of-touch commander-in-chief who waited two days after Katrina struck before cutting short his vacation. Rove used Katrina to push the administration’s failed ideologies on the Gulf Coast, advocating segregated schools, reduced pay for low-wage reconstruction workers, and limited government health care. Political allies received large no-bid contracts. Americans were outraged. A CBS News poll six months after the hurricane found that just32 percent of the public approved of the way Bush handled the disaster.

The one area in which Rove succeeded was the politicization of the government’s response to national tragedies. This week, current FEMA head R. David Paulson, promised, “I do not see this country allowing another Katrina-type event.” But that type of event—and Rove’s politicization—is playing out right now, in Utah, at collapse of the Crandall Canyon mine.

The political crony overseeing the government’s response is Mine Safety and Health Administration (MSHA) head Richard Stickler, who spent 30 years as a coal company manager with Beth Energy. The Senate twice rejected Stickler’s nomination because the mines he managed “incurred injury rates double the national average,” so he had to rely on a 2006 recess appointment by Bush.

Like both Brownie and Rove, Stickler has been tragically inept at leading a crisis. By law, MSHA is supposed to be in charge of managing the Utah mine tragedy. But Stickler largely stepped aside and allowed the mine’s owner, Bob Murray, to control the disaster. It took MSHA at least two days to gain public control of the situation. In an Aug. 7 press briefing, Murray used a media appearance to criticize global warming proponents, and only later “emphasized that his heart and his priorities are with the trapped miners and their families.” Many experts have also questioned why MSHA allowed “anyone, including rescuers, into the still-dangerous mine.”

Throughout his administration, Bush has allowed political considerations to outweigh safety concerns about mining. According to a 2006 AFL-CIO analysis, the Bush administration has cut 170 positions from MSHA. It has also decreased major fines for safety violations, and in many cases, has failed to collect any fines at all. Instead, Bush appointed former coal industry officials like Stickler and J. Steven Griles, the Deputy Interior Secretary who was recently sentenced to 10 months in prison in the Jack Abramoff lobbying scandal. Additionally, the coal industry has donated approximately $10.6 million to Republicans since the 2000 election cycle.

After the Sago mine disaster last year in West Virginia, which killed 12 workers, Bush promised, “We’ll do everything possible to prevent accidents.” Less than a year later, more miners are dead because of lax regulations and a mismanaged response. There’s no reason to believe that the federal government is more able to prevent another Katrina-type tragedy.

Rove thinks he is lucky. The media have already turned their attention away from him and back to stories about whether Hillary is tough enough, Barack is experienced enough, and Lindsay Lohan is sober enough. But with the anniversary of Katrina and the tragic Crandall Canyon mine collapse, attention—and outrage—should be focused on Rove’s dangerous legacy one last time.

• subscribe to print magazine

  First Name Last Name Home Address City State Zip Code Email

  2-year, 24-issues, $44.95 1-year, 12-issue, $24.95

• stay in touch with our email newsletter

  Subscribe to our regular weekly e-mail newsletter. It's packed with updates on recent and upcoming stories, events, campaigns and things every progressive should be informed about. Check out a sample.

   

• email this article to a friend

  Your Name Your Email Recipient Email

  Personal message Thought you might be interested in this article from In These Times.

   

  Please help us prevent spam by verifying the word you see in the image above

  Send to multiple recipients. Just separate each email address with a comma.

• Reader Comments

  There seem’s to be quite a bounty of megalomen from Texas.  Maybe it’s the oil, maybe it was J.R. Ewing.  But even before him there was Frank Lorenzo.  It’s a bit disconcerting, that this state that use to be it’s own country, and has produced the likes of Delay and Bush, has half of the nation’s plutonium buried at Armarillo.  (aprox. 32 TONS) Should Texas seceed from the nation, they have the oil refineries, this trump card de nuclear, and the gall to do so.  Delay and Rove could be the first Czar and Rasputin.

  Posted by juangault on Aug 27, 2007 at 12:21 PM

  juangault,

  Thanks for the comment. Agreed, there are quite a few Bush friends from Texas, but they are largely dropping off. Gonzales’s resignation today marked the departure of one of the last remaining Texas posse—Dan Bartlett, Harriet Miers, etc. Karen Hughes is still around, but she’s at the State Department. One of the few people left is Clay Johnson, who, perhaps not surprisingly, is being discussed as the next DHS Secretary (if Chertoff takes the AG job).

  Posted by aterkel on Aug 27, 2007 at 3:47 PM

  The rage from a lack of justice could very well spill over and afflict completely innocent people.  Remember the image at the beginning of the Rodney King riots with the white truck driver, at the wrong place and wrong time? 

  Looks like we’re going to have a century of dynasty in this decaying carcass of a nation.  I’d vote for Laura if she could somehow get W to close the trunk of her car on his tie right before she took a long road trip across Tejas.  I think the Republicans deserve another 30 yr hiatus for their indiscretion of dancing with the Texmanian Devils.

  Posted by juangault on Sep 3, 2007 at 5:21 PM

• register a new account »Posting Security

  To participate in our forums, please register for a free account.

  Username Password

    Remember me
  

  Retreive lost password »

Member Login

Also by Amanda Terkel

• Mining Roves Katrina Legacy
  Rove was the man President Bush quietly put in charge of overseeing the administration's response plan, though he had no expertise in homeland security or disaster relief

Your financial support of In These Times is critical, because as Thomas Jefferson said, "Information is the currency of democracy." And information doesn't come cheap.

Donate now and get a Kurt Vonnegut mug or t-shirt!