Culture » November 5, 2008

Moore Than You or Me

Slacker Uprising offers nothing new, but it will be worth something if it affects November’s election

By Michael Atkinson

Filmmaker Michael Moore speaks during the 2004 Slacker Uprising tour.

The marrow of Moore's schtick has always been the dialectic between appalling corporate facts about American inequity, and the witty, hypocrisy-skewering stunts he contrives around them.

Whatever you say about filmmaker Michael Moore, we should consider ourselves blessed to have such a professional agent provocateur running amuck in our national media circus, raising the heartland’s consciousness and making the fat cats furious. We should as well take satisfaction that the corporate system — however pervasive, powerful and profit-mandated — is helpless to stop him.

No matter Moore’s persona — however much he chafes and self-promotes — he is one of the few uncompromised progressive voices in the American mainstream, and he’s easily the most visible.

Yet Moore is loathed — not merely by conservatives — but also by Democrats and liberals of all stripes, who apparently cannot abide Moore’s affected working-class-Michigan profile and his shameless knack for self-aggrandizing and demagoguery. But it’s clear to me that Moore’s public showmanship and character are media tools, and the tasks he applies them to are always righteous and necessary.

This puts critics and educated liberals in a bind, because Moore’s films are not for us. They’re pedagogic acts, aiming low, and are less important in and of themselves than the public awareness and influence they might produce, in the millions of voters and consumers who don’t read In These Times, watch Keith Olbermann or read the new anti-Bush hardcovers.

If we’re delighted by documentaries like Bowling for Columbine, Fahrenheit 9/11 or Sicko, it’s only because we are the converted, watching our rage being sung to the heavens and hoping a Florida swing voter is listening with us. Other viewers, blue-collar voters in Colorado, Florida and Ohio, say, might learn something.

Of all of his films and TV shows, Moore’s new Slacker Uprising — available free as a download online — might be the camel’s-back-breaking straw for many Moore-wary viewers.

Little more than a filmed record of Moore’s 2004 get-out-the-vote national tour, the film hops from state to state, college arena to college arena, as Moore rallies students to vote against President Bush in more than 60 cities.

The marrow of Moore’s schtick has always been the dialectic between appalling corporate facts about American inequity, and the witty, hypocrisy-skewering stunts he contrives around them.

But there’s almost none of that in Slacker Uprising.

The 90-odd-minute feature is made up almost entirely of Moore taking the stage in front of one screaming, full-throated student audience after another, and then bellowing simplistic aphorisms at them. Occasionally guest stars appear — musicians Eddie Vedder, R.E.M. and Steve Earle, and actor Viggo Mortenson — to no great purpose.

The movie tries to make a thrilling narrative out of Moore’s tour, but a few censorship squabbles aside, there’s no news in it. A montage of uproarious, idiotic Bush supporters leavens the repetition a bit, as does a climactic, heart-sinking recap of the poll-slip suffered by Sen. John Kerry (D-Mass.) in the home stretch running up to Election Day 2004.

But Slacker Uprising is empty as protest satire goes, and it lends a cudgel to those who think Moore does what he does for the sheer sake of ego and power.

Time and time again we’re presented with the spectacle of Moore’s shambling form being hailed by thousands of roaring college kids as if he were a messiah figure — an idea that has no relation to reality (rallying college kids like to scream and shake their fists and see famous people).

But here, distilled and edited down into a parade of glory moments, the routine comes off as vaguely distasteful, even suspicious. Couple that with the swooping rock-concert camera pans over the crowd, and relentlessly anthemic music, and what you’ve got is a strained attempt to get us mindlessly riled and on Moore’s bandwagon without the benefit of having been told anything new — or even having heard a good wisecrack.

Still, however egomaniacal Moore may be, his tour helped get a record 21 million young voters out in 2004. And the decision to offer the film for free in the fall of 2008 is clearly spurred by a desire to affect the turnout of this cycle.

In both situations, it’s hard to imagine that Slacker Uprising will influence the judgment of any but the most naive and most easily impressed 19-year-old.

Of course, we all hope it might — or hope anything might — and so it’s difficult to accuse Moore of exploitation when the perfect end product of his labors would be a fair economy and the end to a cretinous foreign policy.

We know Moore’s campaign failed in ‘04, a bedevilment Moore attributes in a final title card to the fact that, although Kerry won the young vote by a landslide, “their parents voted for Bush.”

What can be done?

Slacker Uprising has its inspiring moments. It’s hard to resist Moore’s calculated but authentic salutes to veterans and serving military, finding them in his massive audiences and then insisting everyone else stand and applaud in gratitude.

Still, how can the movie significantly contribute to a Democrat win this November, when the presumably exhausting tour itself did little to alter the outcome of Kerry vs. Bush?

We all do what we can, but let’s face it: Love his baseball cap and folksy manner or not, Moore still does more than you or me, and a pitcher without his best stuff is still playing the game.

• Help In These Times publish more articles like this. Donate today!
• Subscribe today and save 46% off the newsstand price!

• subscribe to print magazine

• stay in touch with our email newsletter

  Subscribe to our regular weekly e-mail newsletter. It's packed with updates on recent and upcoming stories, events, campaigns and things every progressive should be informed about.

   

• email this article to a friend

  Your Name Your Email Recipient Email

  Personal message Thought you might be interested in this article from In These Times.

   

  Please help us prevent spam by verifying the word you see in the image above

  Send to multiple recipients. Just separate each email address with a comma.

• Reader Comments

  Uh ..... nobody much cares about Michael Moore, but we would like to be able to comment on the Bill Ayers article.  Why are comments shut off there?

  Posted by Natalie on Nov 9, 2008 at 11:46 PM

  Uh ... Michael Moore has been a successful and patriotic filmmaker of conscience for decades now. Like most visionaries, it takes the masses a while to catch-up. Gee, I still remember the coast to coast booing he got for speaking the truth in front of a presumed ‘librul’ Hollywood audience.

  Same for Ayers who says that the lessons of the 60s; wars of aggression and civil rights, have yet to be learned [witness Prop 8 in CA]. Ayers paid for his crimes as a Weatherman, inspired by the black and white, patriotic sense of right and wrong patriotism of his youth, and is now a respected college professor; but we’d never know that either.

  The ownership class and their minion-media-myth-makers of American exceptionalism are what keeps the nation from facing it past to address its future.

  Posted by hourglass on Nov 10, 2008 at 9:03 AM

• register a new account »Posting Security

  To participate in our forums, please register for a free account.

  Username Password

    Remember me
  

  Retreive lost password »

Also featured On a Mission From God
An Unfolding Crisis in the Wake of Mississippi ICE Raid
The Selma of Immigration Rights

Full contents
Previous issues
Subscribe and save!

Also by Michael Atkinson

• Always Look on the Bright Side of Genocide
  When did the Holocaust become morally ambiguous?Posted on March 5, 2009
• A Massacre in 3/4 Time
  Waltz with Bashir is hallucinatory, relentless, and amazing.Posted on February 3, 2009
• Errol Morris’ Myopia
  Filmmaker Errol Morris has grown famous and revered as the pioneer of what… morePosted on May 13, 2008
• Iraq: Mismanagement or Mass Murder?
  No End in Sight explores how we got into Iraq and what screw-ups have made the situation spiral out of controlPosted on July 24, 2007
• Iraq on the Big Screen
  Who should define what a war is "about"? By any ethical standard, that… morePosted on June 6, 2006