Views » February 13, 2004

Pride Before the Fall

By Cynthia Moothart

It was a stunning show of hubris. An act so offensive it should have been unthinkable. Timed to cause the greatest pain and the deepest outrage.

But then it was this president. And it did advance his standing among right-wing extremists.

The recess appointment of Charles W. Pickering Sr. to the Fifth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals is an attack on civil rights and the progress toward social justice made in the last half-century. Equally odious is the timing—Pickering was implanted on the bench as Americans prepared to celebrate the birthday of Martin Luther King Jr.

You remember Pickering: He’s the federal judge in Mississippi who disapproved of the Voting Rights Act, calling the one-person, one-vote doctrine “obtrusive.” And who attempted to force prosecutors to drop charges against a Klansman already convicted of burning a cross in the yard of an interracial couple with a young child.

Civil rights and judicial watchdog groups are rightfully outraged over the appointment, but it should have come as no surprise—after all this is a president who used Supreme Court pals to steal office and paved the road to war with lies.

But Bush’s action, as it seeks to bolster his standing, does pose problems for the party—and suggests a creeping awareness within the White House that he soon could face his political mortality given approval ratings now below 50 percent.

Republicans have spent the last three years condemning Senate Democrats for playing politics with the judicial nomination process, given they blocked six of the president’s most egregious nominees. (In Pickering’s case this happened twice—during the year and a half Democrats held the majority on the Judiciary Committee and again through filibuster after they lost control of the Senate following the elections in 2002.) But such claims have no standing.

Already Bush has appointed 169 judges to lifetime seats on the federal bench and 30 more to federal appellate courts—equal to President Clinton’s total in his first four years in office.

And there simply is no more blatant a political ploy than slipping a discredited zealot through the backdoor and onto the bench, as Bush did in mid-January to galvanize his right-wing base.

Republicans have sought cover by claiming that the White House did nothing more than Bush’s predecessor. With dozens of nominees stalled by Senate Republicans and seeking to end the nation’s longest-standing court vacancy, President Clinton temporarily seated Roger Gregory on the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals. He was the first African American appointed to the Fourth Circuit, then the federal jurisdiction with the largest black population.

But the depth of Republican hypocrisy is belied by this one fact: With the strong backing of Gregory’s two home senators, Bush officially nominated the former Virginia litigator, who sailed through confirmation on a vote of 93-1. (It’s worth noting that deposed Senate Majority Leader Trent Lott was the lone dissenter.)

Pickering will not undo generations of advances in civil rights during the year he has been given to serve. But this cynical political act draws attention to those lifetime apointees who could—and will fuel efforts to unseat their champion.

Remember classical literature. Hubris, such excessive pride and ambition as characterized in Bush’s move, typically lead to the downfall of the hero, in this case the guardian of extremist right-wing causes. Come November, voters will have the opportunity to write the last chapter in this president’s ruin.

• Help In These Times publish more articles like this. Donate today!
• Subscribe today and save 46% off the newsstand price!

• subscribe to print magazine

• stay in touch with our email newsletter

  Subscribe to our regular weekly e-mail newsletter. It's packed with updates on recent and upcoming stories, events, campaigns and things every progressive should be informed about.

   

• email this article to a friend

  Your Name Your Email Recipient Email

  Personal message Thought you might be interested in this article from In These Times.

   

  Please help us prevent spam by verifying the word you see in the image above

  Send to multiple recipients. Just separate each email address with a comma.

• Reader Comments

  I can’t believe that Bush and his administration keep doing all this stuff and getting away with it.  The main stream media does nothing to get the message out to the everyday people who need to know.  Thank you and a few others on the internet, for helping to keep us informed.

  Posted by Carol on Feb 14, 2004 at 3:30 AM

  President Bush seems to be setting up his agenda’s publically and politically, snubbing his nose at our freedoms. I voted for Bush but the more I see and read and understand his agenda, the less I care for the guy. Looks like I am a Democrat Now!!!

  Posted by Jim Walker on Feb 14, 2004 at 6:25 AM

  Let’s get dubya and his fellow thugs out of Washington and into federal pens, by joining the effort to impeach this turkey and his fellow creeps; Big-oil Cheney, dumb-assed Rummy, Herr Asscroft of the USA-SS, and for god-sake, Karl Rove (aka Dubya)!

  Posted by Alan Taylor on Feb 14, 2004 at 7:04 AM

  It is such a shame that this man has gotton away with everything all of his life, and now he has ruined this country, and it will take forever to get it back. So come november lets take our country back from all these war hawks, and send them back to Texas where they belong. We need honest people in the White House, and not these lying people, that have done so much damage. And i cant believe how so many people believe in them. WAKE UP PEOPLE AND SEE WHATS GOING ON. They sure didn’t have a hard time looking in Clintons affair, which did not kill anyone. This President started a War that was about WMD, but where are they, GOOD QUESTION????????????

  Posted by Rose on Feb 14, 2004 at 10:35 PM

  Great article!

  Posted by Ed Mellon on Feb 18, 2004 at 2:12 AM

• extended discussion >>>Continued...

  Discussions with more than 5 comments are continued on our special discussion page to encourage continuity and ease of use. There are currently 9 posts.

Also featured Faulty Intelligence
Jobs Not Well Done
Judicial Disappointments

Full contents
Previous issues
Subscribe and save!

Also by Cynthia Moothart

• Beyond God, Guns and Gays
  Tuesday marked Election Day—not a trendPosted on November 4, 2004
• The Grand Delusion
  George W. Bush shamelessly boasts that he doesn’t read. Of newspapers he said:… morePosted on August 20, 2004
• Grasping at Straw Men
  Moments after John Edwards was named Democratic vice presidential candidate, the Republican National… morePosted on July 12, 2004
• Media Culpa
  I confess, I’m a sycophant, even if my bootlicking inclines less toward, oh… morePosted on June 12, 2004
• Down and Soon Out
  Labeling them un-American and a stain on our collective honor, President Bush expressed… morePosted on May 25, 2004