Who should define what a war is "about"? By any ethical standard, that right should fall to the besieged--those who were waged upon, the people with the most corpses and the least to gain from combat. Of course, in reality, an armed conflict's character is [RETURN TO ARTICLE]
FOLLOW US
Also by Michael Atkinson
-
Required Viewing: 2011’s Top Political Films
From The Black Power Mixtape to Werner Herzog's Into the Abyss, here's what you need to watch now.
MORE » -
The Secrets, Lies and Elisions of J. Edgar
Clint Eastwood's biopic of the FBI Director inventively avoids the massive damage he inflicted.
MORE » -
George Clooney: The Man From Yesterday
Ides of March isn't great, but at least its director and star actually cares about politics, history and memory.
MORE »
SUPPORT INDEPENDENT MEDIA
Invest in the news you need. In These Times is a nonprofit, reader-supported magazine and website.
subscribe today for $19.95!
SAVE 53% OFFTHE NEWSSTAND PRICE!
MOST READ
- Why Conservatives Can’t Fix Poverty
- The Girl’s Guide to Staying Safe Online
- Siri and the High-Tech Gender Gap
- It’s the Stupid Republicans, Stupid
- True Crime Finance Stories
- Is the Federal Government Helping to Bust Unions?
- Anger Sowing Seeds of a New Consumer Movement
- What Can Labor Learn?
- Marching Off the Cliff
- New Eden, Old Devils

Reader Comments
If only our soldiers would stop murdering the innocent Iraqis, then the Sunnis and Shiites (and Kurds too) could live in peace. Praise be unto Allah.
Jesus, Woof. Ain’t it a drag when you can’t get the respect you know you deserve? Go play in the traffic on some freeper site. Someone there is bound to wrap an American flag around your sad, silly, sorry ass, and salute.
This article stars with a good example of what I like about liberals,
Well, Wolfie
it was a peaceful enough place BEFORE your troops went in to make home-movies about their heroism.
WTH
grieving parents are not only American. VERY few of THEM compared to the many many thousands of Iraqis.
SORRY. Forgot those ones are not HUMAN. They are just collateral damage, WE don’t do body-counts.
IF you like WAR, at a safe distance like Wolfie, do not whinge about your casualties.
Hmmmmmmmmmm. Definitely hypocritical, there. They signed up for patriotism, a college education, or Adventure, whatever, and they PAID .
It was a gamble, with yellow ribbons galore, and WTH and Wolfie cheering them on, from the sidelines, of course.
register a new account »Posting Security