At last year’s Sundance Film Festival, an angry audience member stood up after the third screening of a film charting four Asian-American teenagers’ descent into petty crime, drugs and murder. “Why would you,” the man addressed Justin Lin, the film’s director, “make a [RETURN TO ARTICLE]
FOLLOW US
Also by Kevin Y. Kim
-
A History Unaccredited
Hip-hop has no standing archives. Like the seminal works of the few who’ve come before—David Toop’...
MORE » -
Inside Al-Jazeera
Samir Khader has covered and observed the war on terror through his work with the Arab news network,...
MORE » -
On an Island of Men
Born in Port-au-Prince to a well-to-do family, Michele Montas’s lifelong passion for journalism led her in the 197...
MORE »
SUPPORT INDEPENDENT MEDIA
Invest in the news you need. In These Times is a nonprofit, reader-supported magazine and website.
subscribe today for $19.95!
SAVE 53% OFFTHE NEWSSTAND PRICE!
MOST READ
- Why Conservatives Can’t Fix Poverty
- The Girl’s Guide to Staying Safe Online
- Siri and the High-Tech Gender Gap
- It’s the Stupid Republicans, Stupid
- True Crime Finance Stories
- Is the Federal Government Helping to Bust Unions?
- Anger Sowing Seeds of a New Consumer Movement
- What Can Labor Learn?
- Marching Off the Cliff
- New Eden, Old Devils

Reader Comments
I HAD THIS FILM AS TOP ON MY LIST!! I WISH I COULD PUT IT HIGHER. THIS REVIEW IS OUTSTANDING. I REGRET THE FILM IS SHOWING ON SO FEW SCREENS IN TUCSON, AZ. IT NEEDS TO BE SEEN AND HEARD!!! I HAVE 2 FILMS THAT NEED TO BE MADE, AS WELL; BUT, THEY ARE HISTORICAL. I THINK THIS FILM SHOULD BE BE IN EVERYONES FACE!!!!!!!!! D.B.
Why would you give away all those plot details and the end of the film in a review??? Anyway, it’s a great movie, I am really inspired by the whole endeavor. Maybe with Justin Lin and crew, America still has a chance at making decent films!
I haven’t watched the movie yet, but I don’t feel like this review revealed so many details and the ending that I can’t enjoy the movie anymore. Rather, I think I’d like to watch this movie now - to see for myself (perhaps even to remind myself of), as Mr. Kim eloquently states, Lin’s portrayal of what is “utterly, piercingly human.” Plus, the movie has been out since last year. This article is not a trailer or a promotional review. It’s an analytical piece analyzing a movie. And you can’t analyze anything well without referring to some of its details. Nevertheless, I feel that Mr. Kim’s essay was more than just a movie critique. It is a social commentary, using the movie to tackle some of the simple yet provocatively complex issues of today’s real life society - youth, violence, to name a few.
register a new account »Posting Security