Unfortunately, I fear Slavoj Zizek's really thoughtful and interesting piece above does not entirely live up to its apt subtitle : "By tying the drama to a mere personal whim, The Lives of Others fails to capture the true horror of the GDR". The French quality newspaper, Le Monde, ran a month ago an interview with Hubertus Knabe, a historian and the curator of the former Stasi main prison and interrogation center in Berlin-Hohenschönhausen, now converted into a national Memorial. Knabe, I think, outlined more effectively the scenario's two fundamental weaknesses, because of which he had finally declined to help with …
All 2 comments by...
Henri, Paris
-
-
Re Diane's comment above : "Since when does fiction have to adhere to facts?" - Well, Hollywood's low standards do not have to apply to the rest of the world, you know. The point is "The Lives of Others" is a German film, NOT an American one, and thus one does not a priori shrug it off as just another mass-produced piece of illiterate fiction made for purely economic reasons. Indeed, as Germans have a reputation for painstaking attention to detail and lack of frivolity, one expects something closer to a documentary than to the wide screen rendition of a video …
Posted to The Dreams of Others
Return to Henri, Paris's profile
- Joined May 27, 2007
- Last Visit June 6, 2007
- URL
- Location Paris
- Occupation Househusband/retired investment banker
- Interests Varied
Other Profiles
IN THESE TIMES COMMUNITY MEMBERS
- 1.
- 2.
- 3.
- 4.
- 5.
- 6.
- 7.
- 8.
Ignoring Outrage, Obama Set to Expand Pentagon Presence in Colombia
- 9.
- 10.
RSS Feed