Features > October 13, 2006

Chinas Growing Desert

Overgrazing is stripping arable lands, creating the potential for ecological refugees

By Jehangir Pocha (Bejing)

As expanding deserts have encroached on Dunhuang, the city has created a 'sand park' where people ride camels and sleigh down dunes.

A new Chinese export has been spreading quietly across Asia and the United States: dust.

Violent sandstorms from China’s expanding deserts have been battering numerous Chinese cities, and now their mustard-colored dust has begun reaching South Korea, Japan and the west coast of North America.

“People dusting off their cars in California or Calgary often don’t realize the sand has come all the way from China,” says Lester Brown, president of the Earth Policy Institute (EPI) in Washington D.C., who was in Beijing recently. “There is a dustbowl developing in China that represents the largest conversion of productive land to desert of any place in the world … and it’s affecting the world.”

China has always suffered from aridity, as about 20 percent of its landmass is comprised of deserts made famous in tales about the Silk Road that traversed many of them.

But the situation is getting worse. Persistent drought, overgrazing, indiscriminate use of ground water and rampant logging are eroding the edges of China’s deserts, allowing them to merge and spread. Recent satellite imagery shows that the Badain Jaran desert in north-central China is pushing southward toward the nearby Tengger desert to form a single, larger desert, overlapping both northwestern Gansu province and neighboring Inner Mongolia.

Expanding deserts swallow almost a million acres of land every year, China’s State Environmental Protection Administration says. Soon 40 percent of China could turn into scrubland, creating massive social, economic and ecological challenges, including the problem of millions of “ecological refugees.”

“When I was a kid, the desert was five kilometers [three miles] away but now it’s right here,” says Li Liang, 19, gesturing to the sand now lining the periphery of his family’s cotton farm just outside Dunhuang in Gansu. “Every year there are sandstorms, and every time there is a sandstorm our cotton is destroyed and we have to replant it, which costs a lot.”

—————————————

Ironically, the Li family’s diminishing profits are rooted in China’s increasing prosperity. The leading cause of China’s desertification is the growing number of sheep and goats being reared in places such as Gansu for China’s increasingly prosperous 1.3 billion people who are eating more and more meat.

China now has 400 million cattle, sheep, goats and yaks, up from 100 million in 1960. Most of these animals are owned by traditional herders who graze them on ecologically fragile hills and steppes, so the animals have uprooted and eaten up vast swathes of grassland. As the topsoil has loosened, strong winds have blown it away, creating massive sandstorms and turning the area into desert.

According to official reports, about 4,000 villages across China have recently been swallowed by the encroaching desert and more than 200 million people are suffering from the effects of desertification.

Significantly, it’s not just tiny hamlets like Li’s that are being threatened. The legendary Gobi desert in central China has expanded by about 25,000 square miles since 1994 and its sands are now within 100 miles of Beijing.

The capital gets blasted by about half a million tons of sand every year, often reducing visibility to the point where even its soaring skyscrapers are barely visible, air traffic stops and people are forced to stay indoors.

Curiously, while such sandstorms seriously impact human health by causing and exacerbating various skin, breathing and eye disorders, they can be quite good for the earth. Often, the minerals transported during sandstorms provide new nutrients to inland ecosystems and the seas, according to the Asian-Pacific Regional Aerosol Characterization Experiment, an international campaign focused on understanding how dust particles affect the chemistry of the atmosphere.

The organization’s researchers say they also want to study how dust changes the quantity of solar energy our planet radiates back into space, something that will enhance our understanding of climate change.

But that’s cold comfort for Yang Jian, director of the Development Planning Department in the Chinese Ministry of Agriculture, who is worried about how China’s desertification will impact food supplies.

Yang says China needs up to 500 million tons of grain every year. While the country is currently self-sufficient in food, production is slipping. The biggest reason for the decline is that about a million acres of arable land have been lost to urban sprawl over the last decade, according to official reports. Though Yang’s ministry has reserved 255 million acres of land for agriculture, much of it is in areas affected by desertification.

If the desert eats substantially into China’s arable land, Beijing will be forced to import grains. This would raise world food prices, a potentially life-threatening shift for the world’s 350 million poor who live on less than $1 a day, Yang says.

—————————————

With official reports also warning that China is losing about $7.7 billion a year because of desertification, the government is trying hard to battle the creeping sands.

Farmer Li says local officials ordered his family to switch from growing cotton to planting trees in the hope that reforesting the desert’s periphery will help contain it. Many counties in Gansu have also restricted herders from grazing their animals on damaged grasslands, and cities such as Beijing are creating “shelter-belts” of grass and trees around themselves.

China is even trying to water arid regions by seeding clouds with silver iodide, which creates “artificial” rain. The chemical, which is sprayed into clouds by plane or cannon shell, cools clouds so their moisture condenses and falls as rain.

So far, the Chinese government has equipped about 35,000 farmers with antique anti-aircraft guns and trained them to fire shells loaded with silver iodide into passing clouds.

But according to Gao Jixi, director of the Institute of Environmental Ecology in Beijing, which studies desertification, even the most innovative measures will not roll back the desert if China’s GDP-growth oriented policies continue to ignore environmental costs.

“It is more important we respect nature’s rules by restoring the original ecological systems in those regions,” Gao says.

But that seems far off: Chinese authoritarian leaders cannot afford to promote any policy that may slow its economy.

“Chinese leaders have a legitimacy problem”, says Jing Huang, senior fellow at the Brookings Institution in Washington D.C. “Their only tools for staying in power are nationalism and economic growth.”

Growth is particularly important in Gansu, Inner Mongolia and other poor western provinces such as Xinjiang and Tibet, which have substantial minority populations. Conscious of how disliked the Communist Party is in these areas, Beijing is trying to win over hearts and minds by delivering economic development.

But the mega public works projects being built in these areas, such as the new 1,300-mile-long railway linking Beijing to Tibet, often take a massive environmental toll.

In Xinjiang, where Muslim Uighurs have launched an armed insurgency to demand independence, Beijing’s attempts to increase irrigation are backfiring. The province’s Tarim River has dried up, and the large poplar groves around it that once served as a barrier between two deserts, the Taklamakan and the Kumtag deserts, are disappearing. As a result, these two parched swathes of sand are merging just like the Badain Jaran and Tengger deserts in Gansu.

The new proximity of the desert to urban centers such as Dunhuang and Beijing has prompted some local entrepreneurs to create “sand parks” where city kids can ride camels, toboggan down dunes and drive SUVs. But charging people so that they can frolic in sand that is literally smothering Chinese villages—and even spreading across the Pacific Ocean—is emblematic of the benign disinterest that overlooks the long-term environmental costs of short-term profits.

The EPI’s Brown says that China is the country that best exemplifies this global problem. Such unbalanced development, he warns, is threatening to spawn catastrophes that could destabilize the entire world.

“Communism [in China and elsewhere] collapsed because it did not calculate the full economic costs of products,” he says. “Now capitalism will collapse if it does not calculate the full environmental costs of things.”

• subscribe to print magazine

  First Name Last Name Home Address City State Zip Code Email

  2-year, 24-issues, $44.95 1-year, 12-issue, $24.95

• stay in touch with our email newsletter

  Subscribe to our regular weekly e-mail newsletter. It's packed with updates on recent and upcoming stories, events, campaigns and things every progressive should be informed about.

   

• email this article to a friend

  Your Name Your Email Recipient Email

  Personal message Thought you might be interested in this article from In These Times.

   

  Please help us prevent spam by verifying the word you see in the image above

  Send to multiple recipients. Just separate each email address with a comma.

• Reader Comments

  The situation in Darfur is caused by increasing deserts. Nomadic desert tribes are being forced to encroach on other peoples land as their watering holes dry up. Desertification can cause wars. Desertification increases global warming.

  When I went to school the solution was reforestation and hydrology studies on a global scale that would recommend solutions to the problem. Why wasn’t this done more vigorously? Part of the reason is that people will have to be moved.  More than likely people would be asked to move to let forests grow and for dams to be built to better manage water resources.  This does not sit well with capitalist and liberal ideologues as they don’t believe that people should be forced to do anything for the greater good.  In fact they claim there is no such a thing as the greater good and the left and right agree that the nation state is sacrosanct and global solutions (the only thing that will work as this is one planet) are a bad idea as they interfere with national sovereignty.

  Anyhow the deserts will grow and we will wonder why and sit on our hands.

  ,,

  Posted by Spinoza750 on Oct 14, 2006 at 10:42 AM

  You can tell China is getting a bit desperate about this if they are having all those farmers shooting shells into the clouds to seed them for rain. And this practice affects natural rain patterns, so where the clouds have more likely released rain in the past, seeding will essentially steal the rain from those areas which over time probably will make those areas drought-prone as well.

  A good book about the world’s water problems is “When the Rivers Run Dry” by Fred Pearce that brings in some of China’s problems. The book jumps to places all over the world where humans have caused the water shortages and literally changed the earth for the worse. There are problems here in the US as well. The Midwest for example is rapidly draining its watertable through corporate farming practices and most people are aware of the overtaxing of water resources in the American Southwest.

  Posted by Jon B on Oct 15, 2006 at 3:54 PM

  The current desertification of China’s valuable agricultural land is one of the many negative impacts of the global economy.  Rising grain prices due to massively increased grain imports could benefit US farmers and, of course, big Agribusiness firms like Cargill and ADM who receive most of the subsidies and control most of the US grain exports. This goes along with the way in which China’s export boom benefits US transnational corporations more than the Chinese workers or their communities. China’s industrial revolution is the most foreign dependant of all four historic industrial revolutions (UK, US, Japan, China) and the most reliant on foreign capital and markets. Though the internal market for increasing quantities of red meat is deemed responsible for the overgrazing of livestock and the desertification it causes, the rising incomes upon which this is based is rooted in China’s foreign spurred industrial revolution and the foreign markets it serves. It is time to bring this process under greater control. China has far greater independance and political ability to cope than other third world countries whose external economic dependancy is causing the same types of ecological problems.

  Posted by cabdriverinchicago on Oct 15, 2006 at 11:15 PM

  I wish we had some sort of agitation to stop the growing deserts which is a world wide phenomena and problem. There is a potential that the growing deserts and melting glaciers are going to increase water shortages. From what I know of the Three Gorges Dam project it should control water usage to a high degree and the lakes formed should be a good source of evaporate water but ideally heavy forest should be planted around the lake to moderate evaporation. Generally forestation is the best way to increase water supplies.  I have heard arguments that one way to increase the value of land and increase water levels in the Tigris Euphrates water region is to greatly increase forests.  This will also have the effect of reducing sand storms.  It is argued that Israels reforestation projects have increased rainfall.

  Posted by Spinoza750 on Oct 16, 2006 at 1:35 AM

  > “Every year there are sandstorms, and every time there is a sandstorm our cotton is destroyed and we have to replant it, which costs a lot

  This is another problem, plowing land loosens the soil and increases evaporation increasing drying conditions.  That was how the dust bowl of the 1920-30’s was made.

  What is needed is to analyze trends 50 years out and institute preventative practices.

  Posted by Spinoza750 on Oct 16, 2006 at 1:42 AM

• extended discussion >>>Continued...

  Discussions with more than 5 comments are continued on our special discussion page to encourage continuity and ease of use. There are currently 6 posts.

Member Login

Also by Jehangir Pocha

• China Plays Hardball with Soft Power
  Out with strongman Mao and in with svelte-suited diplomats and film personalities: Chinese leaders have learned the value of a warm smile and firm handshake
• Eyes Off the Prize
  As Iraq dominates U.S. attention, China, India and Iran are emerging as the next world powers
• Rebiya Kadeer: The Uighur Dalai Lama
  Falsely imprisoned, this human rights activist is fighting the Chinese government's right to rule her people.
• Chinas Growing Desert
  Overgrazing is stripping arable lands, creating the potential for ecological refugees
• China Dissidents Disappeared
  Officials round up 'bad elements' as the National People's Congress starts its session
• When Red Goes Green
  A burgeoning Chinese environmental movement tries to stem the devastation wrought by the country's massive economic transformation.