Working In These Times
Labor Advocates, Unions Split Over Single Payer
Nurses and healthcare activists rallied in Los Angeles last April to urge the passage of the United States National Health Insurance Act. Now, organizers are set to converge upon Washington, D.C. to urge action on healthcare reform. (ROBYN BECK/AFP/Getty Images)
As Democrats in Congress try to bridge differences on healthcare reform legislation, grassroots groups will converge on Washington Thursday to commemorate the 44th anniversary of the passage of Medicare and urge members of Congress to extend its coverage to everyone.
Although most unions are fighting to make sure that the proposed legislation includes a public option, mandates employers to provide or at least contribute to employees’ insurance, and avoids taxing health insurance benefits, unions will be strongly represented in the push for a single-payer (or Medicare-for-all) solution.
560 labor organizations, including 39 state federations and 130 central labor councils, have now endorsed the Medicare-for-all bill introduced by Michigan Democratic Rep. John Conyers. (The bill is formerly called The United States National Health Insurance Act; a parallel Senate bill was introduced by Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt.) While a few unions are pushing for single-payer—most forcefully the California Nurses Association (CNA)—and others have formally endorsed the idea, nearly all are promoting some variant of the Congressional Democratic proposals.
Although systematically excluded from the health reform debate, Medicare-for-all inspires deep passion among supporters as the best policy to guarantee universal healthcare (as even Obama acknowledged in his latest prime-time press conference) and drastically control costs.
Not even most supporters expect there’s much chance single-payer could win in this session, but they want the public and politicians to recognize its merits. So New York Rep. Anthony Weiner plans to introduce an amendment to substitute HR 676 for the House tri-committee bill in the Energy and Commerce Committee, perhaps on Friday. And Sanders has promised to take similar action on the Senate floor.
But the CNA and many labor single-payer advocates are focusing on preserving Ohio Democratic Rep. Dennis Kucinich’s amendment granting states the right to adopt single-payer plans as an alternative to setting up insurance exchanges. Kucinich’s amendment passed the Education and Labor Committee on July 17 by a 25 to 19 vote, with strong Republican support and mainly Democratic opposition.
“If the door [to single-payer] is going to be closed in this Congress,” says CNA national legislative and political director Joe Jurczak, “let’s see if we can pry it open with the state option.”
Canada’s single-payer system emerged from provincial initiatives, and California’s legislature has voted twice to set up state single-payer insurance, only to be vetoed by Gov. Arnold Schwarznegger.
Many labor single-payer advocates doubt that the public option, which is the focus of much union advocacy, will be strong enough to justify support for a bill that they see as deeply flawed. “There’s already a public option that works–called Medicare,” Jurczak says. “Why not extend it?”
“There’s a real possibility we could do more damage” with the Democrats’ “hybrid bill,” argues Kay Tillow, organizer of the All Unions Committee for Single Payer. “At best it’s a plan that doesn’t solve the problem.”
Mark Dudzic, organizer for the Labor Campaign for Single-Payer Healthcare, a coalition formed last winter, said that “the decision still has to be made whether these [Democratic] bills are something we don’t want to stand in the way of or they’re so horrible for working people we have to oppose them.” Dudzic doesn’t want to be accused of blocking reform, but he worries that a bad plan with a weak public option could end up discrediting the public role in healthcare. “It’s a set-up for failure,” he says.
Beyond influencing the debate in Congress, labor single-payer advocates hope to sharpen the discussion on health policy in the labor movement, starting with resolutions for the AFL-CIO convention in September. Then they will persevere, Tillow says, to “build the movement until it’s politically possible” to win their goal.

SAVE 53% OFF
Comments
Our country is embroiled in controversy and debate over health care reform. Focus on the purpose of health care has been lost. Health care has two purposes:
1. Keep people healthy.
2. Get people well when sick.
Barack Obama and the Democrats have killed single-payer universal health care which was by far the most popular alternative. Now they are confusing the issue with talk about a “public option” when the only real “public option” is something like VA or the Indian Health Service; both of which could be combined and expanded to include everyone under a Public Health Service.
Our public officials squander our limited and scarce resources—- during a period of a crumbling economy—- financing wars in three countries; subsidizing the Israeli military machine; and spending trillions of dollars financing 800 U.S. military bases on foreign soil dotting the globe; and then they tell us there is no money for health care. Instead, we should be building 800 public health care centers stretching out across the United States providing a public health care system which includes:
• No-fees/No premiums
• Comprehensive (cradle to grave)
• All-inclusive (general, dental, eyes, physical therapy, prescription drugs)
• Universal (everybody in; nobody out)
• Publicly funded
• Publicly administered
• Publicly delivered
The United States is the wealthiest country in the world.
We can afford to provide a first-rate, world-class, free public health care system for our own people—- if we get our priorities straight.
We need health care reform based upon: Everybody in; all the profiteers out.
Health care is supposed to be about people, a human right; not about profits.
Representing workers employed in smoke-filled casinos suffering from cancers and heart & lung problems, I know a little something about why we need health care reform now.
Alan L. Maki
Director of Organizing,
Midwest Casino Workers Organizing Council
58891 County Road 13
Warroad, Minnesota 56763
Phone: 218-386-2432
Cell: 651-587-5541
E-mail: .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)