Working In These Times

Sunday Jan 10, 2010 6:53 am

Sex Workers Risk Violence, Arrest—What Can be Done?

By Kari Lydersen
How do you protect your rights as a worker if the very job you are doing is illegal?

Studies have shown sex work is one of the more dangerous jobs out there. December 17 marked an international day to end violence against sex workers.

The high profile "Craigslist killing" last spring was just one example of the risks sex workers face on the job every day. Physical violence is common, as is wage theft, not to mention the emotional toll taken by handling social stigma and the constant risk of arrest.

Sex workers advocacy groups are often at odds as to how to best protect the rights and needs of sex workers. Some groups and advocates say targeting “demand” is essential to reducing violence against sex workers and helping them leave the lifestyle if they so choose. They often advocate increasing law enforcement action against johns and pimps while de-criminalizing sex work itself, not legalizing it but rather steering sex workers to resources and social services instead of criminal proceedings.

The Chicago Alliance Against Sexual Exploitation has been a leader on this front, including working with the Cook County sheriff to sue Craig’s List over its erotic services listings. That lawsuit was dropped in October.

Other groups, including the Sex Workers Outreach Project (SWOP, covered previously on this blog by Michelle Chen) and the Desiree Alliance, oppose the idea of ending demand by targeting clients of sex work with criminal prosecution and things like “John School.” They say such measures end up hurting women (and men) engaged in sex work, by increasing law enforcement involvement in the issue as a whole and making it harder for sex workers to make a living.

These differing approaches have made for much contention especially around anti-trafficking legislation and policy. But there is nearly unanimous agreement in the field that sex workers are denied the most basic workers' rights,  including the right to be paid in full for services rendered, to not be physically or mentally harmed and the right not to be forced to work against one’s will. These of course could be considered not only basic workers' rights but essential human rightsy—yet they are violated regularly and with impunity in the course of many sex workers’ lives.

On July 25-30, the Desiree Alliance is holding its national conference in Las Vegas, described as “a national convergence of sex workers and our allies to help build a stronger and more diverse sex worker rights movement and create discussion surrounding the issues many sex workers face today.”

Proposals for presentations are open through March 1; one does not need to be a sex worker to suggest a presentation or work shop. Organizers are seeking proposals specifically on five tracks: Academic and Policy, Activism,  Arts & Media, Business Development, and Harm Reduction and Outreach. (Proposals can be sent to Desiree2010@desireealliance.org. Additionally, discounted advance registration closes Jan. 15.)

The previous two conferences were held in Chicago and San Francisco. Last year’s theme was “Sex work and social justice.”

Serpent, a co-founder of the Chicago Sex Workers Outreach Project, thinks the rights of sex workers have gained much awareness in recent years, but there’s still a long way to go.

“People need to understand, ‘Hey it’s just a job like any other job,’” she said.

2 comments  · 

Comments

Frank (Pancho) Valdez 11 Jan 2010
9:35 am

It appears that “experts” are good at stating what needs to be done with opposing views. I wonder what do the sex workers think? Has anyone bothered to get their input?

I recall back in 1973 a group of female sex workers were trying to organize a union. Just wondering what became of that effort?

Personally I believe that the laws prohibiting prostitution are neither fair or totally enforceable. Why prosecute women (and men) who are just trying to earn a living?
Those in need of drug treatment should be able to get it.
Pimps and violent johns need to be prosecuted to the furthest extent of the law.

Hell, if Jesus had no problem in associating with them, why should they be stigmatized and outlawed?

Kari Lydersen 11 Jan 2010
9:52 am

All the groups mentioned in my post are made up primarily of current and former sex workers, so yes sex workers themselves are definitely leading the debate on this issue, on both or all sides. And I think sex workers and their advocates pretty much agree that women and men just trying to earn a living should not be prosecuted and should get any treatment they need. I know there is at least one actual union of sex workers (at the Lusty Lady in San Francisco), there are probably other official unions, meanwhile groups like SWOP aim to in many ways serve the same function as a union in terms of promoting workers rights…

Please Login to Comment register a new account »

To participate in discussions, please register an account.

retrieve lost password »